Bill Simmons Alleges “I Don’t Read Sports Blogs”; Murky Syntax Saves Zoe Simmons’ Life

You pick the "your" tweet, Simmons?

I really don’t care about the “Simmons steals!” “controversy” (Basketball Prospectus’ John Gasaway nailed the only essential point to be made), but I do care about Simmons professing some aversion to sports blogs.

Why? Because he’s lying. (Probably. Maybe.)

Obviously, the tweet in question is from yesterday, December 4th. So it is possible that Simmons is telling the truth about not reading sports blogs right now.

But let’s look at a quote from a Mediaite interview this July:

1. How do you get your first news of the day?

ESPN.com, RealClearSports, hoopshype, Buster Olney’s baseball blog, Mike Lombardi’s football blog, Deadline Hollywood Daily, Drudge Report, TV Tattle, Google Trends, my Twitter page.

That would be two blogs mentioned by name; RealClearSports, half-blog, half-aggregator of blogs (and visited by Simmons no later than October 26th at least; and HoopsHype, which is a blog if MLB Trade Rumors is. But, hey, you “don’t read sports blogs.”

Let’s take it further back: In July, Simmons responded to a post at The Big Lead with an email, and in May, he fired off this tweet in response to this post, which implies that he is at least aware that Deadspin and TBL post daily.

How about his April podcast with Rick Reilly? Simmons was frustrated with the “accuracy” of blogs then, though he did say:

This is the way (young writers are) going to get heard, and maybe they make some mistakes in how they’re trying to get heard, but for the most part, I think it’s a good thing, ultimately.

So blogs are “a good thing” but Simmons doesn’t read them, despite being a sports writer currently writing only on the Internet? Okay. Sure.

The Will Leitch roast post was a one-off thing, so that doesn’t count. The Basketball Blog died a swift death.

But let’s ask the question: Nothing Bill Simmons reads on the Internet comes from sports blogs? All the information he takes in is from basic mainstream media sources, or from TV, or from his own inbox? The Wayne Winston post he mentions here was just fed to him without him ever visiting the site?

We can classify Simmons as a sports blog “reader,” if not a devotee, for going to the sites he claims he visits daily; it is also fair to assert he “reads” sports blog by going to links that are blogs that people send him. I don’t think there’s any way “I don’t read sports blogs” is true by those measures.

Simmons likely means to say “I don’t regularly read sports blogs,” which makes a lot more sense. Certainly, it would take a lot of time for someone who writes about sports for a (handsome) living to read the viewpoints and prose of other writers on sports from the newspaper and mainstream website realm, even without venturing into the blogosphere.

I don’t buy it, though. I still think Simmons reads a number of blogs—probably some rotation of Deadspin, TBL, RCS, SportsByBrooks, and a few others&mdas;that give him a very shallow understanding of what’s bubbling in sports opinion and what’s shaking in sports media. (Fire Jay Mariotti concurs, and remembers this tweet, which I didn’t.)

I think that he thinks that shallow understanding is quite enough of a dip into the cesspool of the blogosphere; one doesn’t swear on a child’s life next to a definitive denial unless that denial is truly meant adamantly.

And I don’t think that’s nearly enough: Shouldn’t a “Sports Guy” whose writings speak to what the average young white male sports fan experiences be reading blogs like those increasingly Internet-fluent, information-devouring dudes are?

Simmons should, when talking about “blogs,” avoid blanket statements that rankle bloggers. (Because that’s how posts like this get written.) But he should also consider engaging with them by both reading and trying to learn from them. He could stand to learn that, in the blogosphere, most don’t "steal ideas", but build upon others’ points to extend the life and value of thoughts.

If he were a little more receptive and intellectually curious, he might not get people on the Internet making snarky jokes in their headlines about how his poorly-phrased tweets endanger his progeny.

About these ads

4 Comments

Filed under Bill Simmons

4 responses to “Bill Simmons Alleges “I Don’t Read Sports Blogs”; Murky Syntax Saves Zoe Simmons’ Life

  1. younglefty

    Solid take. I think part of the reason for his statement is the lingering hesitance to acknowledge blogs, for fear of “legitimizing” them. A better tactic would probably be to go ahead and acknowledge their existence (they’re not going anywhere), and take on their positions on merit. Then again, that makes too much sense. Well written piece, Rock.

  2. John Doe

    Thanks for sharing your opinion, but I feel like you’re coming off like your were personally hurt by Bill Simmons’ statement. Somewhat harsh, I’d say. You’re calling him unreceptive and not “intellectually curious,” and I don’t think you personally know the man so please refrain from slandering others in your blogs. I could sit here and pick apart your argument down to the last detail, but I’d rather not give you a grammar lesson and tips on structure, so I’m going to leave you with what I hope are helpful tips when dealing with topics of people and their words: Don’t commit slander or libel, respect paid authors, don’t try to guess as to what people mean in their statements, and don’t put extra words into their mouths or try to twist quotes into something they’re not; this is how blogs get bad reputations, and probably why Bill Simmons doesn’t read them (And reading blogs from accredited sources is not the same as reading blogs from average joes). Thank you for sharing your thoughts, and please take into consideration my critique.

    • I find it amusing that a person who implies that reading blogs from average joes is a lesser pursuit than reading from “accredited” sources then signs his comment with “John Doe.”

      If you come brandishing accusations of libel and slander, you should probably know what you’re talking about.

      And if you want to give me a grammar lesson and tips on structure, feel free. I do take into consideration all critiques of my work.

      I doubt “paid author” Bill Simmons does, and certainly doubt that he takes them from anonymous sources.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s